Marvel Comics Cover Gallery - 1958

COMPARED TO 1957, MARVEL'S OUTPUT FOR 1958 was a pretty sorry-looking affair. From a high of 45 titles in April 1957, their output had plummeted to just eight comics a month, a consequence of Martin Goodman's attempt to chisel a few extra dollars by folding his own Atlas Distribution and signing a contract with the doomed American News Company (ANC). It didn't end well.

JANUARY 1958

Although cover-dated for the first month on 1958, this batch of titles - no longer Atlas, but not yet Marvels - went on sale during September 1957.

Click image to enlarge

The lineup consisted of two romance books, two teen humour titles, two westerns, a war book and a kiddie comic, Homer the Happy Casper ripoff. This would remain the lineup for most of the year.

Though Stan had been made to let most of the Bullpen go, Joe Maneely was still one of his go-to artists, providing the cover art for Gunsmoke Western and Kid Colt. The romance titles continued with covers by the Vince Colletta studio. Dan De Carlo, not yet departed for Archie, drew covers for Homer and Millie and the war comic cover was by Bill Everett. These may have been inventory pieces, but as the year wore on, Stan would have to start commissioning again.

FEBRUARY 1958

Similarly, the even-numbered months in 1958 carried on with the same lineup that Goodman had instigated at the end of 1957, when his comic line was up and running again. Of these February-dated books the earliest on sale was Strange Tales 61 on 27 Sep 1957 and the latest was Patsy Walker 75 on 28 Oct 1957.

Click image to enlarge

That month gave us a pair of war books (covers by Bill Everett) and couple of teen humour titles (art by Patsy regular Al Hartley), two westerns (covers by Joe Maneely) and a brace of mystery books long-time Marvel stalwarts Bill Everett on Strange Tales and Carl Burgos on World of Fantasy.

Looking at the output for these first two months, it dawned on me that there was a reason why, in the early 1960s just as the superhero books were getting started, Stan hired second-string writers to script the superhero stories in Journey into Mystery, Strange Tales, Tales of Suspense and Tales to Astonish, while keeping the westerns and the Millie and Patsy books for himself. He must have feared the superhero bubble would burst and that his time was better spent keeping the sales of the non-heroes books on track by writing those himself. Later in the 1960s he would do the opposite, farming out Millie and Sgt Fury to new assistant Roy Thomas while handling all the super-hero books himself.

MARCH 1958

The March-dated Marvels continued in very much the same vein, the lineup matching January's exactly, and on sale late October to early November 1957. I would imagine Goodman would have been very reluctant to change his portfolio this early into the process. He'd be waiting for initial sales figures to come in before doing any tweaking. But he would start tweaking. Any guesses as to what got deep-sixed and what got the old Goodman "match and hatch"? No peeking, though ...

Click image to enlarge

The western covers were again by Joe Maneely. Dan De Carlo drew the Homer and the Millie covers, and Colletta was responsible for the art on the two romance covers. Patsy Walker artist Al Hartley drew the Miss America cover and the Marines in Battle cover was by another of Stan's close personal friends, Fred Kida.

APRIL 1958

It's not a surprise, then, that the April post-Atlas comics were the same titles as we saw in February. On sale from late November to early December 1957.

Click image to enlarge.

The Battle and World of Fantasy covers were by Bill Everett, the Navy Combat, Two-Gun Kid and Strange Tales were Joe Maneely efforts. The two Patsy covers were, as expected, by Al Hartley. The Wyatt Earp cover was by John Severin.

MAY 1958

With still no change in the lineup, the May cover-dated titles went on sale across the holiday period, from late December 1957 to early January 1958.

Click the image to enlarge.

The Gunsmoke Western, Kid Colt Outlaw and Marines in Battle covers were by Joe Maneely. Dan De Carlo did the Homer and the Millie covers. The two romance covers were by Vince Colletta, or his studio. Al Hartley provided the cover for Miss America.

JUNE 1958

The post-Atlas titles cover-dated for June went on sale between 28 Jan 1958 (Strange Tales) and 25 Feb (Patsy Walker). Presumably, the rest fall somewhere in between.

Click the image to enlarge.

Bill Everett contributed cover art for the two mystery titles, and Joe Maneely was responsible for the Navy Combat cover and the two western books. The other war cover was by John Severin. The two Patsy covers were, of course, by Al Hartley.

JULY 1958

Of the July cover-dated comics, Kid Colt was on sale earliest on 25 Feb 1958. Almost a month later, readers got to peruse the Gunsmoke Western on 27 Mar 1958. Goodness knows when the rest hit the newsstands, but it'll likely have been between those two dates.

Click the image to enlarge.

Vince Colletta provided the pencils and ins for the two romance titles. The western books and the Marines in Battle comic all had cover art by Joe Maneely. The covers for Homer and Millie were drawn by Dan De Carlo and Al Hartley contributed the cover to Miss America.

AUGUST 1958

The only definitive on-sale dates I could find for the August pre-Marvel comics were for Patsy Walker and Strange Tales, both hitting the stands on 27 Mar 1958. My best guess is the remainder would have been before the end of April.

Click the image to enlarge.

Joe Maneely was especially busy this month, drawing the covers for Battle, Navy Combat, Strange Tales, Two-Gun Kid and Wyatt Earp. Al Hartley came second, pencilling and inking the two Patsy covers. Limping along in the rear was Bill Everett with his cover for World of Fantasy.

SEPTEMBER 1958

Of all the September cover-dated issues, only Kid Colt - Outlaw is given an on-sale date by GCD - 25 Apr 1958. Judging by some of the above on-sale date ranges, it seems safe to conclude that the remainder of the September titles would have been on sale from end of April to end of May. Unless someone knows differently.

Click the image to enlarge.

Of these covers, the westerns were both by Joe Maneely, Homer and Millie were both by Dan De Carlo. The Marines in Battle - which would be the final issue - featured Carl Burgos art and Miss America's cover was by Al Hartley. While the My Own Romance is probably entirely Vince Colletta, or at least his studio, there is some speculation that the Love Romances cover may have been pencilled by Matt Baker. Baker did a fair bit of work for Atlas (and Charlton) after the Comics Code shut down his main customer St John. Ironically, it was Baker's cover for Phantom Lady 17 (Apr 1948) that gave weight to Frederic Wertham's case that comics needed regulating.

OCTOBER 1958

I was only able to find definitive on-sale dates for Patsy Walker (26 Jun 1958) and Strange Tales (24 June1958). The rest of the titles would likely have been on the newsstands earlier in the month. As the sales figures started to come in, Goodman began tweaking his lineup. The war books would have been the lowest sellers, as this month he also cancelled Navy Combat.

Click the image to enlarge.

In another bumper month for Joe Maneely, Stan commissioned him to draw covers for Navy Combat, Strange Tales, Two-Gun Kid, World of Fantasy and Wyatt Earp. That same month he also drew 19 interior pages for Two-Gun Kid, 17 interior pages for Charlton's Wyatt Earp title, another five pages for Charlton's Tex Ritter and five pages for Cracked magazine (no surprise as editor Sol Brodsky used many Marvel stalwarts at that time). The other Marvel covers were picked up by Al Hartley on the two Patsy titles, and Fred Kida contributing the cover for Battle.

NOVEMBER 1958

With Marines in Battle out of the way, Goodman was free to replace it with something he thought might sell better. It's a safe bet that the mystery titles were doing well, because Uncle Marty took the opportunity to reinstate a veteran Atlas title, Journey into Mystery, noted by GCD as being on sale 27 Jul 1958. The same source has Kid Colt on the newsstands on 26 Jun 1958. The rest would have fallen between those two dates.

Click the image to enlarge.

Stan's go-to guy Joe Maneely drew the covers for Gunsmoke Western, Kid Colt - Outlaw and Journey into Mystery (though I'm really not sure about the face on the guy at bottom right). Matt Baker (with Colletta on inks) was the credited cover artist for the Love Romances, and probably for the My Own Romance, too. As before, Millie and Homer were drawn by Dan De Carlo and Al Hartley provided the Miss America cover.

DECEMBER 1958

The year was rounded out with another substitution. Martin Goodman took Navy Combat off the field and brought on a new mystery title, Strange Worlds. It's an odd decision, because skinflint that he was, Goodman might have saved a few dollars by reviving one of his cancelled mystery titles. Yet he went to the time and trouble to fire up a new comic starting with number 1. Yes, Strange Worlds had more of a science fiction slant (Marty was always late the the party, as the sf movie boom had really gotten underway in the early 1950s), but still ... money is money. I wonder if it might have had something to do with the new artist Stan was welcoming to the Bullpen ... Jack Kirby.

The December pre-Marvels went to the news vendors between Strange Tales' 25 Jul 1958 and Patsy Walker's 2 Sep 1958.

Click the image to enlarge.

Naturally enough, the cover for Strange Worlds was pencilled by Kirby and inked by Atlas regular Christopher Rule, as was the cover for World of Fantasy. The production dates for these issue would have been around late May to early June, so it would have been just a couple of weeks before Joe Maneely's terrible fatal accident. 

The covers for Battle, Strange Tales and Wyatt Earp would have been some of the last pieces he drew for Stan. The two Patsy covers were by Al Hartley, as you might expect and EC's Jack Davis was the cover artist for Two-Gun Kid, and drew two interior stories, one of which had a Joe Maneely splash page. It's likely that was Joe's last bit of work for Stan, and that Davis drew the remaining pages of the story. Joe Maneely was just 32.

Next: The Other Best Marvel Comics Annual